Shapes




Depending on whom you listen to, the Village (Church & Wellesley) is either dead, on life support or just going through a renaissance period of rebirth and reinvention. While die-hards stand by the venerable Village steadfastly, many on the Street and in the media are sounding the death knell as bars and businesses shut shop for good or for lower rents in other areas. Is Church Street dead or merely resting?

Bars and bistros are vanishing from the Village

The supposed slide began a few years ago as a few Church Street landmarks like Crews/Tango and Bar 501 shut their doors. Soon, others followed winding up in an apotheosis of “Closed” signs that saw Zelda’s at its zenith. One by one bars and bistros have been vanishing from the Village leaving many to ponder, “Who’s next to go?” and “What the hell is going on?”

Opinions are flying like towels in a bathhouse as to what is happening on Canada’s most famous queer strip of real estate. Some are blaming skyrocketing rents while others are wondering if the bars and bathhouses that historically have attracted so many are the reason why the core audience is abandoning ship. After all, you can only drink and party so much until it’s time to pay the piper (or in this case, the credit cards, rent or mortgage). The population is also ageing and with that comes a shift in priorities. The party boys of the 80s are now middle age men who may be feeling the physical affects of all that indulgence or have moved on to pastures with picket fences.

Is the Village still relevant?

Gentrification—and “queerification”—of other neighbourhoods just outside the core have become the new stomping and nesting grounds for the upwardly mobile homosexual as of late. Areas like Parkdale, Queen West, Leslieville and the Beach have booming gay Boomer populations as queer couples go off to raise families in more “kid-friendly” areas where real estate is affordable and a good long-term investment. Around these “enclaves” have sprouted up cafés, shops, pubs and bars where gays and straights of all ages and ethnicities mingle merrily over mochaccinos or martinis.

Is this a natural attrition that happens in a ghettoized area that was once ground zero for the gay rights movement in Canada or is the Village succumbing to its own party-till-you-drop manifesto? Are the last of the Village Vanguard dropping? Is the Village merely going through a metamorphosis? Do we still need a ‘gay ghetto’? Is the Village still relevant?

I’ll be moderating two panel discussions called Bent Village to explore the state and fate of the Village. Panelists include: David Wootton - Church Wellesley BIA; Tom Warner- Coalition for Lesbian and Gay Rights in Ontario (CLGRO); Nick Mulé – Queer Ontario and Kristyn Wong-Tam – Local Queer Activist

The first evening is:
Tuesday, February 23, 2010, 7:00pm to 9:00pm
Gladstone Hotel Art Bar, 1214 Queen Street West

The second evening is:
Sunday, February 28, 2010, 4:00pm to 6:00pm
Gladaman’s Den, 502A Yonge Street

Admission is FREE. Your feedback, ideas and input are encouraged! See you there.

Learn more on our Facebook Bent Events page and RSVP.

4 Comments For This Post

  1. Justin Says:

    I don’t think it’s over for our queer village. I do think everything constantly changes, and that we look at this and call it wrong. It’s not, it’s just different to what it was. Church & Wellesley has something no other neighbourhood in Canada has: history. C&W is where everyone thinks of first when they think of somewhere gay to go, safe to be gay, to celebrate Pride. Also, Pride Fm and Xtra/fab are anchors there (we keep referring to restaurants and bars but there are other anchors). NOt that I read them though. GGT is the only queer publication I give my time to these days. But that’s not the topic here is it? Keep up the good work!

  2. Dean Garrard Says:

    Looking at the village these days I try to find the good in it but with all the people begging for money, the closing of the venues, the dull lifeless looks of people walking down the street and the look of time standing still it is hard to.

    When I first came out in my mid 20′s the village was a paradise and a place to be myself without worrying about being gay. I grew into my gayness living down near the village and met my adopted family (close friends) throught life there. Boots was my 2nd home as was colby’s and life was good; I felt comfortable being there.

    Then slowly things started to change…

    Boots closed down and became a hotel then 2nd cup closed down and slowly piece by piece the village was disappearing. The happy faces of friends and people around me changed to people who felt lost and whom started to look at the village as a prision more then a paradise.

    As time went on I moved outta the area to the east end and then to Mississauga where I currently am residing and find myself now rarely going to the village not because it takes too long to get their (I have a car so it’s 20 mins to get there) but the fact that the same people are at the same places doing the same thing week after week after week. THe barn and Woody’s which once held the term (Hot places) are now just another place in the village.

    If the village is to remain the paradise and sanctuary for the GLBT community it is going to have to do a major reconstruction to bring back the true village life. I hold on to the memmories of my past and hope oneday that that love and life will come back and smiles and true “gay-ness” will be restored. We hold pride every year to be proud of ourselves yet we have no pride in our village…With 2014 comming we might have to think about that and finally stand up and say “Bring back our village to the way it was” when you were scared to go into the Black Eagle for fear of getting whipped (Not talking about gardening and furniture decked out in leather as it is now in the backroom)or going to the Barn and fly and feeling the energy of people dancing around you or going into Woody’s and feeling that you belong.

    Bring back my paradise!

  3. Tim Devlin Says:

    Is the Village Dead or dyeing? Firstly the rents are a factor and property owners have sucked the profit out of every business but the business’ are to blame as well.
    We do have an aging Queen Scene in the Village but there is nothing for us except Timothy’s. Why Timothy’s? Because we can actually SIT DOWN we can actually HEAR EACH OTHER TALK. We can actually SOCIALIZE AS OPPOSED TO CRUISE.
    Everything in the Village has been aimed at the Twinkie and designed by Twinkies….LOUD…STROBE ATMOSPHERE where your suppose to stand around bobbing your head like a chicken never talking..never hearing. The thing is the Twinkies don’t spend money and they don’t really support the village.
    WHAT IS THE TARGET MARKET OF THE VILLAGE? All target markets must be money makers if your to survive.
    Our street may be clean but it looks run down and dirty. We need to attract Gay Friendly outsiders to support bars and restaurants etc. BUT we need to understand older people will not STAND for hours…GOING DEAF…and never speaking. Every night out can’t be to make out. You must define HOW THE HELL DO WE HAVE A SOCIAL EVENING. Sattler’s had it right with JUST THE PIANO but then they stuck mikes everywhere so you couldn’t talk at all and then they decided it had to be a Cabaret where you sat dutifully and listened…NO SOCIALIZING ALLOWED.
    The Gay community is a Social Community or it is NOT a community it’s a bunch of sex hungry Fags standing around having a Viagra moment and not even knowing what language the guy your cruising speaks. Bars are not willing to evolve and experiment with the needs of today. I think Drags are fabulous but Gay isn’t really about Drag anymore.
    I’m in Fabulous Gay Thailand and Paradise Village here is world famous but it’s dyeing because it’s 1960′s and they won’t change. Every venue is competing to see who can be the loudest. Your deaf by the time you start home and the Twinkies look and don’t spend…the older set would spend but have a fucking headache from the noise. If you want to choose a Money Boy … do it quick and get out before you go mad. Everything looks run down like Christopher Isherwood’s Cabaret of the 1930′s. Ugly, MAKESHIFT. These old Gay Villages belong in a theme park like Disney Land.
    All society is becoming about “ME, ME, ME” my Tech shit…my personal I-Pod, my personal Trainer, My personal strawberry flavored blue toothed Blackberry in shocking pink. Nobody is aware of anyone unless they want to fuck him because we’ve killed the art of socializing.
    What makes Timothy’s work? They know their clients, they give their clients what they want .. not what they want them to have. A lot has to do with good business sense.
    I know the owners and staff of Timothy’s by name and can actually speak to them or chat to a stranger next to me, or rest my ass and read the paper…so that’s where I spend my dollars. And the village won’t work if people don’t know what its about and can’t be bothered to try and re-live their youth. If Madonna can re-invent herself every year why can’t the business in the village?
    Business is about Supply and Demand…the Village does not supply the demand. The BIA had great idea’s about the visual image but did nothing. The Village survival depends on establishing a marketable image that attracts not only Gays but straights as well. Fill the bars and restaurants by catering to the customer.
    Forget the vanity business…”Oh, I’m going to open a Bar in Shocking Pink with feathers on the Ceiling” not what the customer wants but who cares what they want. That’s the problem.
    Kill the property landlords for gouging…get historic status for the landmark village. Identify your target market and serve them and if you don’t want to….then get out. Until someone does some market research in Gay villages around the world and discovers what is working…nothing will work.
    Actually now we have equality …. are we a society at all?

    Other than that….HAVING A WONDERFUL TIME!

    Tim Devlin,
    [email protected]

  4. Tim Devlin Says:

    And further more Gay Pride is going to end up like the Village, An historic event of no significance aimed at Twinkies who have no idea why they’re proud or that they are part of a once beaten, murdered, robbed, brutalized and fabulously glamorous society who wore designer everything, had great hair cuts, grooming and were all trend setters. Now we’re all ads for cheap cloths at the Goodwill.
    Today’s gay scene is like Harrison Ford making another Indiana Jones film with a walker…move on. What are we now ….are we just straight guys who happen to suck dick?
    Don’t they all?
    We’ve got to blend with the straight community like the ingredients in a fabulous cupcake…only we must be the Thick, gooey, frosting everyone want to lick…not the paper liner they throw away.

    Tim Devlin,

    [email protected]

Leave a Reply